Jerusalem court upholds women’s prayer rights at Western Wall

JERUSALEM (RNS) Women who want to wear prayer shawls while praying in the women’s section of the Western Wall are not breaking the law, according to a landmark decision handed down Thursday (April 25) by the Jerusalem District Court.

Israeli police arrested five women on April 11 who were dressed in prayer shawls while praying with Women of the Wall, an activist group that prays at Judaism’s most sacred site once a month. (Josie Setzler, who just returned from a trip to Israel, wrote about the protest and arrests for Toledo Faith & Values.)

Despite a 2003 Supreme Court decision stating women cannot don prayer shawls at the Western Wall, many members and supporters of Women of the Wall pray with prayer shawls. They want the Israeli government to accommodate the needs of all Jews at the Wall, not just those of the ultra-Orthodox.

Despite a 2003 Supreme Court decision stating women cannot don prayer shawls at the Western Wall, many members and supporters of Women of the Wall pray with prayer shawls. They want the Israeli government to accommodate the needs of all Jews at the Wall, not just those of the ultra-Orthodox.

Immediately following those arrests, a lower court judge ruled that the women had not violated “local custom,” a legal concept intended to keep the fragile peace at holy sites. The Western Wall is a remnant of the Second Temple that was destroyed nearly 2,000 years ago.

Thursday’s ruling by the higher court upheld that ruling and rejected an appeal filed by the police, who argued Women of the Wall’s practices violate a 2003 Supreme Court decision and disrupt the public order.

Israel’s ultra-Orthodox religious establishment has long maintained that the group’s practices offend more traditional Jews, who believe only men are allowed to lead group prayers or wear prayer shawls.

Following Thursday’s ruling, Anat Hoffman, the group’s chairwoman, said that “today, Women of the Wall liberated the Western Wall for all Jewish people. … We did it for the great diversity of Jews in the world, all of whom deserve to pray according to their belief and custom at the Western Wall.”

Shira Pruce, the group’s spokeswoman, said the struggle will continue until they see “girls permitted to have a bat mitzvah (coming of age ceremony) at the Wall with a Torah, with a tallit (prayer shawl) , or however they wish and believe.”

In a statement, Natan Sharansky, the chairman of the Jewish Agency and a government emissary charged with trying to quell the dispute, said the ruling “only strengthen(s) the need for a sustainable, agreed solution, which will allow every Jew to feel at home at the Western Wall, as the basis for any resolution.” Sharansky had recently proposed adding a third egalitarian section that would allow mixed-gender prayers.

A spokesperson for the Justice Ministry told the Times of Israel that it was too soon to comment on a possible appeal by the state prosecutor to the Supreme Court. A police spokesman could not be reached for comment

 

Print Friendly

0 Responses to “Jerusalem court upholds women’s prayer rights at Western Wall”

  1. Josie Setzler

    Thanks for sharing this news article, David. When I wrote last week on this issue, I was interested primarily in the women’s rights angle. As I reflect on it further, however, I’m struck by the dilemma raised by having the police who represent the state enforce a preference for a particular religious sect, Orthodox Jews, in a public space. In the US, separation of church and state protects us from this kind of problem. This principal works well to preserve religious freedom in a pluralistic society. Reading the newspapers while I was in Israel suggested to me that there is a good deal of pluralism in Israeli society that will need to be respected. The new Israeli finance minister is making waves in that arena as well, as he addresses certain financial privileges enjoyed by ultra-Orthodox Jewish citizens.

Comments are closed.